New finding: Even when Lake Erie’s algae leaves, health threat remains

Tom Henry

Tom Henry

PUT-IN-BAY, Ohio — Western Lake Erie’s noxious algae will start to dissipate in about a month and begin its gradual exit like an unwanted guest that stayed too long at the party it crashed.

An early- to mid-October departure of the harmful blue-green algae known as microcystis is not that unusual, even though scientists are getting uneasy about it arriving earlier and staying later as the Earth’s climate warms.

But what they’ve recently discovered is what this unwelcome visitor leaves behind: toxins capable of damaging your central nervous system.

In extreme cases, there may even be enough residue to kill you.

Scientists have known for years that microcystis, the most prevalent type of toxic blue-green  algae in Lake Erie and other parts of the Great Lakes region, poses a potentially lethal threat to humans and wildlife when it peaks.

In the mid-1990s, a U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention team went to South America for a major investigation after microcystin, the toxin in microcystis, killed 75 people at a kidney dialysis center in Brazil. The center’s water-filtration system had broken down, exposing a highly vulnerable group of people to water contaminated by the toxin.

But as the years passed, scientists realized the toxin continues to live outside of the algae bloom, at least longer than previously thought.

GreatLakesWatchLogo      The toxin may linger in the water for weeks, possibly months, after the biggest visual, the algae bloom, is gone.

Linda Merchant-Masonbrink, coordinator of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency inland lakes and source water protection programs, told Great Lakes writers recently that the public cannot rely on the conventional wisdom of assuming the toxin’s gone once the algae disappears.

The pea-green goop disappears after fall temperatures arrive and the water cools.

But not necessarily the toxin.

Merchant-Masonbrink told writers recently at Ohio State University’s Stone Laboratory on Gibraltar Island, near Put-in-Bay, that microcystis toxins are colorless, odorless, and water soluable.

And, she said, nobody has any good data yet on how durable they are.

Jeff Reutter, the lab’s director and head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration-funded Ohio Sea Grant program, called that a new development.

Indeed, it is.

Not that many people are out swimming or water-skiing in Lake Erie in November.

And, truth be told, shoreline communities have done a pretty good job of tracking microcystis and its toxin. Modern treatment is effective at keeping them out of the public water supply.

But the lingering effect of the toxin associated with microcystis is a potential wake-up call for those who believe there is no problem if you can’t see or smell it. The rank odors and sheer ugliness of toxic blue-green algae keeps most people away from it in the first place – though not always dogs.

Merchant-Masonbrink agreed this makes the communication challenges even more difficult.

Having a hard time getting people to take microcystis seriously? Try telling them it not only moves around, influenced largely by wind direction, but that its concentrations could vary a great deal only a few feet apart and — oh, yes — the toxin they need to worry about could remain hidden in the water long after the algae appears to have gone.

Microcystis has 80 known types of toxins.

Microcystin — LR is the most common and toxic. It has been found in Lake Erie in concentrations that far exceed World Health Organization standards.

At its most intense concentration, it is between DDT and dioxin for toxicity, Merchant-Masonbrink said.

“These are serious toxins,” she said. “These are not to be sneezed at.”

The best advice?

Keep your distance from areas known to have had toxins, Merchant-Masonbrink said.

Also, stick to the fillets of fish you eat. Toxins concentrate in the fish guts, she said.

Algal blooms in Lake Erie. Photo: NOAA

Algal blooms in Lake Erie. Photo: NOAA

Her comments underscore the need to reduce runoff from crop farms and livestock operations, from sewage overflows and all other phosphorus sources that help algae grow.

Scientists have found the most crucial time to curb runoff is March 1 through April 30, said Gail Hesse, executive director of the Ohio Lake Erie Commission. That commission is a panel comprised of Ohio’s state agency directors.

Scotts, the nation’s largest manufacturer of fertilizer, is based in Marysville, Ohio, northwest of Columbus. Starting this year, it eliminated phosphorus from its lawn care products, Hesse said, although she noted it has not been removed from all products.

Hesse, a former northwest district chief for the Ohio EPA, agreed the lack of testing for Lake Erie toxins from 1995 to 2007 shows how algae threats have been misunderstood.

Microcystis became abundant in western Lake Erie in the summer of 1995 for the first time since the early 1970s, when the United States and Canada began to modernize sewage treatment as directed under the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement and America’s Clean Water Act.

It has reappeared almost annually with large swaths between Monroe and Sandusky.

Microcystis has been in other parts of the Great Lakes, too, but typically grows more in western Lake Erie because it’s warmer, shallower, has more people and more land-use impacts.

Less is known about an invasive algae from the South that was found in the region a few years ago, lyngbya wollei. It is typically long strands that clump up near the shoreline, including Lake Erie’s Maumee Bay. At high concentrations, it can cause skin rashes, blisters and tumors, Merchant-Masonbrink said.

Not all forms of algae are bad.

Justin Chaffin, Stone Lab research coordinator and senior limnologist, said there are hundreds of algae species in Lake Erie, many of which help produce plankton that supports the food web for fish.

The imbalance can be found across the world. China, Europe and Africa also have algae problems. The common denominator is the release of excessive fertilizers, waste and other nutrients, Chaffin said.

For many species, including microcystis, toxins are released while algae cells die, Merchant-Masonbrink said.

Sunlight helps kill the toxins, but only near the water’s surface, she said.



3 thoughts on “New finding: Even when Lake Erie’s algae leaves, health threat remains

  1. The EPA and Coast Guard under this administration have no concern for ships spreading these problems throughout the Great Lakes with ballast water systems as illustrated by their policy to give ships used on Great Lakes a pass to avoid installing technology.

  2. Joe, I googled your ice boom. Sounds like the boom is funneling the ice/packing/concentrating it, creating underwater ice bulldozers, pushing material it normaly wouldn’t without the boom. My plates pretty full to get into it more, but it’s not natural, so there is a cause and effect going on. I’m not sure how it affects algae except perhaps destroying spawning grounds, interesting, at least your thinking. I have a small goldfish pond, I pruned some trees, the sun hits it, full of algae, no phosphorus loading, just the sun. There’s no zooplankton either, the goldfish would just eat it, they eat mosquito larvae now, works great. All the facts I can find algae blooms coincide with too many zooplankton eaters, no zooplankton even natural algae has no choice but to rot on the bottom. Now we have extra algae so the zebra/quaggas ain’t getting it all. Stop dumping extra phosphorus, sure, but restore natures algae control, the health of the entire fishery depends on it. No zooplankton no fish!

  3. This is the same thing as when you ask a cancer patient (that is dying) how they are doing and they respond “oh I’m having a good day, not to much pain.” They are still dying. Lake Erie, the Niagara River and Lake Ontario are dying a slow and painful death to their respective ecosystems. The stalled ice conveyor is the cause and the Ice Boom is the suspect. Take a long hard look at “Ice Boom Theory” by Googling “Joe Barrett/Ice Boom” and see if you can find even 1 thing that doesn’t make perfect sense. I dare you. Then help me. I double dare you. THX. JBB

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *