Belle Isle study lights way for savings


Belle Isle at night. Image: Pure Michigan

By Eric Freedman
Capital News Service

The installation of a state-of-the-art street lighting system on Belle Isle – located on the Michigan side of the Detroit River across from Windsor, Ontario – was a major step forward in saving energy and electricity while improving safety for visitors.

Now five years later, a new study says computer optimization modeling could lead to even further savings and other benefits, such as fewer crashes, for communities that upgrade their street light systems.

In 2017, Detroit’s Public Lighting Authority replaced 506 high-pressure sodium lights with 193 solar-powered lights for Belle Isle’s major roads and intersections.

New computer modeling shows the number of replacement lights could have been as low as 170 while providing maximum coverage on the 987-acre island and saving about $100,000 on new poles and operating costs, according to the study by researchers at the University of Toledo, Metro Engineering Solutions in Livonia, which designed and installed Belle Isle’s replacement lights, Southern Illinois University and China’s Wuhan University in China.

Belle Isle was established as a city park in 1845 and became a state park in 2014 under a 30-year lease. Major attractions include the Belle Isle Aquarium, Anna Scripps Whitcomb Conservatory, Belle Isle Nature Center and Dossin Great Lakes Museum.

It drew 5.2 million visitors in fiscal year 2021, according to the Department of Natural Resources (DNR), which manages the park.

“We would like more people to be aware of this optimization model, especially nontechnical people who may not be aware of these tools,” said study coauthor Yue Zhang, an associate professor in the Department of Information Operations and Technology Management at the University of Toledo.

The planning process considers such factors as height and spacing of lamp posts, type of road surface, glare, and coverage distance. For example, street lights should cover the centerline of every road and at least two lights should cover intersections, according to the study.

The study, recently published in the “International Journal of Geo-Information,” emphasized societal payoffs from more effective street lighting beyond economic and energy savings and improved traffic safety.

“Street lighting plays an indispensable role in supporting economic, social and environmental activities,” it said. “There are profound perceived benefits for human well-being, such as increasing opportunities for economically productive activity, energy-saving activity and social interaction activity.”

Street lighting, it continued “reduces time consumption for work and social activities, facilitates leisure and recreational activities and reduces crime and vehicle accident rates.”

Replacement lighting in Belle Isle Park benefits public safety there, said Ed Golder, a DNR public information officer.

However, he said, “the presence of personnel from the DNR Law Enforcement Division and the State Police has had a more significant impact.” Most of DNR’s enforcement activity there relates to traffic violations.

The University of Toledo’s Zhang said mathematical optimization methodology has been used in manufacturing for decades, but his team’s work integrates it with geographic information systems, or GIS, for large-scale applications such as street lighting planning.

It’s the “science of better,” he said.

Had the same planning approach been implemented citywide when the authority rebuilt Detroit 65,000 street lights in 2016, that savings would have been at least $28 million, the study said.

The intensity of the savings is quite significant, the study said, and the extra money could have been used for other projects, such as improved lighting in specific areas or “places with a high crime rate, where the incidence of traffic accidents is high or where there are many pedestrians at night.”

One thought on “Belle Isle study lights way for savings

  1. Saving taxpayers’ money is a good thing. But protecting the health of the same is equal if not better. While LED lighting does reduce energy use and the resulting carbon footprint, the tendency to add more and/or more powerful lighting is a problem.

    This a problem that American Medical Association (AMA) has recognized as detrimental to human health due to overexposure to strong blue-rich lighting and light pollution in general. With a wide variety of human medical maladies linked to the same, light pollution is a threat to all facets of environmental health.

    Luckily, unlike other forms of pollution, light pollution is easy to correct. Just turn off the light! If the light is needed, make a point to utilize lighting with a color temperature of 3000k or less. Also, ensure that the light fixture itself is fully shielded to focus the light downward where intended.

    LEDs are a wonderful way to reduce our energy consumption but they can hide a dark side, pun intended. Don’t make the mistake of overlighting because of their money-saving capabilities. Michigan is a beautiful state. And with the proper use of outdoor lighting, it can be just as beautiful at night as during the day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *