By Nick Kipper
Capital News Service
Michigan electric utilities in 2016 generated nearly 1.5 million tons of coal ash, a waste material that can threaten water with arsenic, lead and mercury, according to a recent report.
The toxic ash is often placed in landfills and waste ponds next to power plants and can contaminate nearby groundwater, according to a Michigan Environmental Council study of data reported for the first time this fall by the state’s 13 coal-fired power plants.
Federal air quality standards in 2015 required utilities to monitor groundwater near their coal ash ponds and publicly post the data. That data was released by individual utilities last January.
“For decades, utilities were essentially allowed to dump this toxic coal ash sludge — which has mercury, arsenic, lead and a whole host of other toxic metals in it — next to coal plants,” said Charlotte Jameson, the author of the report.
DTE Energy’s Monroe coal plant accounted for more than half of the coal ash generated in the state.
These toxic metals leach into the ground and surface water over time, Jameson said.
Human exposure can lead to cancer, cardiovascular disease, neurological disorders, kidney and liver damage and lowered IQ in children, according to the National Center for Biotechnology Information based in Bethesda, Maryland.
Of the 22 coal ash sites listed in the report, 17 showed levels of toxic chemicals like arsenic and lead above state and federal drinking water standards in the groundwater aquifers nearby.
Experts are unsure if this contamination will eventually migrate into drinking water.
“The issue is these utilities just started monitoring this, so we’re still trying to gauge what the threat to drinking water could be,” Jameson said. “We do know that if you let it go unchecked there will be unintended consequences 10, 20 or 30 years down the line.”
It’s likely that the annual amount produced will decline. Coal-powered plants accounted for 37 percent of the state’s net electricity generation in 2017, down from 50 percent in 2016.
Michigan’s two largest utilities, DTE Energy and Consumers Energy, have already begun to phase out coal in favor of natural gas. DTE Energy plans to halt all use of coal by 2050 and Consumers Energy by 2040.
“Over the years we’ll see more coal plants coming offline and that will obviously help in terms of having less toxic waste that we have to manage,” Jameson said. “In the meantime, if we don’t start closing and retrofitting the ponds that are contaminating our groundwater, this is going to continue to be an issue moving forward.”
The Shiras Power Plant in Marquette permanently switched to natural gas in June after a two-year process to end coal production, Noreen Collins, the executive assistant and community relations coordinator at the Marquette Board of Light and Power, wrote in an email.
The Presque Isle Power Plant, also in Marquette and operated by We Energies, generated 54,000 tons of coal ash in 2016 — 3.8 percent of the state’s total.
The plant is set to be replaced by two natural gas-fueled facilities in 2020.
Natural gas creates about the same amount of energy as coal but with half the carbon dioxide emissions, said Nate Verhanovitz, a performance engineer at the T.B. Simon Power Plant on Michigan State University’s campus.
Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas that contributes to global warming.
Verhanovitz was on the team that converted MSU’s power plant from partially coal-burning to completely powered by natural gas in 2016. The recent addition of solar-powered carports provides 5 percent of the electricity used on campus.
“It takes a tremendous amount of natural gas to supply a power plant, so historically it has been more expensive than coal,” Verhanovitz said. “For many power plants that have accessible natural gas that has now flipped.”
|Coal Ash Generated by Coal Plants in Michigan (2016) by Plant Name||Coal Residual Annual Amount Generated (Thousand Tons)*|
|Monroe (Monroe, MI)||756.2|
|JH Campbell (West Olive, MI)||156.1|
|Belle River (St. Clair County, MI)||153.9|
|St. Clair (St. Clair County, MI)||96.3|
|Trenton Channel (Trenton, MI)||60.2|
|DE Karn (Essexville, MI)||55.2|
|Presque Isle (Marquette, MI)||54|
|River Rouge (River Rouge, MI)||29.5|
|Erickson (Lansing, MI)||23.3|
|Eckert (Lansing, MI)||19|
|BC Cobb (Muskegon, MI)||16.1|
|JR Whiting (Erie, MI)||10.2|
|JC Weadock (Essexville, MI)||9.2|
*Data compiled by Michigan Environmental Council from Energy Information Administration, “Power Plant Operations Report,” (Form 2016 EIA-923), 8/17/2018 https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia923/ Some plants have been closed since the data was reported.