By Gabrielle Nelson
IMAGE: A world-record koi weighing 24.5 pounds and three other “monster” koi were removed from Glen Lake where they are an invasive species. Credit: Robert Karner
Robert Karner and the Glen Lake Association are on a mission to preserve the crystal-clear waters of Glen Lake next to Sleeping Bear Dunes and protect its ecosystem from invasive species.
That includes Eurasian watermilfoil and one that’s gaining attention, Japanese koi.
In May, bowfishers partnered with the association, a preservation and protection organization for the 46 square miles of the Glen Lake/Crystal River watershed, caught and removed four invasive koi from Little Glen Lake on the Leelanau Peninsula.
“Not all invasive species are actionable,” or able to be removed, once they are introduced to a lake or river, said Karner, a biologist at the Glen Lake Association. “But a big fish like Japanese koi, at least that’s something we think is manageable.”
The removal is part of a three-year effort to remove invasive koi from the lake to protect native plants and animals.
And these aren’t your typical domestic pond koi – they’re “Japanese koi monsters,” said Karner.
“I was totally dumbfounded,” he said when he saw the size of the koi.
The largest fish weighed 24.5 pounds, breaking the world record for biggest koi caught bowfishing. Three of the four koi, a type of carp, were females with bellies full of eggs, said Karner.
Glen Lake residents first sighted the koi six years ago. But in 2023, when preservation scientists were using drone footage to keep an eye on the spread of another invasive species called Eurasian milfoil, a seaweed-like plant, they spotted bright orange fish in the images.
The native fish of Glen Lake are not bright orange.
They knew the fish were the koi that were reported years ago.
The next spring, during the koi spawning season, Karner and his team took the opportunity to remove the koi before they could become a bigger problem.
To catch the fast, intelligent monster fish, they took an unconventional approach. The Glen Lake Association and the Michigan Department of Natural Resources teamed up with bowfishers from the Thundering Aspens Sportsman Club.
“We had a choice to do nothing or try something we’ve never tried before,” he said. “We think it was pretty successful.”
The bowfishers removed the koi from the lake before they could reproduce and become a greater threat, and Karner said the bowfishers will return in the spring for the next two years to remove two or three more koi that they know are still in the lake.
Koi, like other invasive carp including feral goldfish, aren’t native to Michigan’s watersheds.
Invasive species have no natural predators and are more resistant to native disease, so they can run amok in lakes, ponds and rivers.
The lake bed of Glen Lake is lush with native aquatic plants that are the foundation to a healthy ecosystem, providing food and shelter for native animals.
But invasive carp tear through these aquatic gardens, damaging the plants and stirring up muck that dirties Glen Lake’s famous clear water.
“These organisms aren’t supposed to be here,” said Kyla Foley, the aquatic invasive species coordinator at the Benzie Conservation District. “Once an invasive species is introduced, it becomes very hard and generally very expensive to manage.”
So prevention is key, she said.
Karner, who’s been tracking the koi in Glen Lake for six years, said the fish likely were pets whose owners released them into the lake.
“They didn’t want to kill them. They didn’t know where to put them, so they let them free,” he said. “That’s the hypothesis.”
A seemingly innocent pet such as a koi, turtle or crayfish can cause major damage to native ecosystems, said Foley.
“If you have pets or aquarium plants and you bought them from a store, it’s always important to make sure that when you’re done with them, you find the appropriate home for them,” she said. “They shouldn’t be released out into the wild.”
Gabrielle Nelson has an environmental reporting internship under the MSU Knight Center for Environmental Journalism’s diversity reporting partnership with the Mott News Collaborative. This story was produced for Bridge Michigan.