By Marissa Gonzalez
Capital News Service
Some environmental advocates are expressing concerns about a Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy (EGLE) proposal that would remove some ozone pollution data from Detroit’s air quality records.
Under the federal Clean Air Act, states may exclude pollution data due to exceptional events such as smoke from wildfires, including those in Canada, that increasingly bring smoky air to Michigan.
According to a posting by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in the Federal Register, EGLE in 2022 first requested Detroit to be redesignated as an “attainment” area, which means it meets the EPA’s air quality standards.
EGLE submitted a more recent draft of the request this May.
If approved by the EPA, the change will result in the removal of 21 days of ozone pollution data over a four-year period from Detroit’s air quality records, according to the Michigan Environmental Council.
The group says that would make it look like Detroit meets the air quality standards, when it does not.
During a recent virtual roundtable discussion hosted by the council, several experts said the state department’s proposal is not a good idea and will cause more harm than good by disregarding the actual ozone pollution levels that Detroiters live with every day.
According to Nicholas Leonard, the executive director of the Great Lakes Environmental Law Center, most of Detroit’s ozone pollution is not due to wildfire smoke, and he said that wildfires should not be considered an exceptional event under the law.

“It’s almost a ‘get out jail free card’ for regulators. By excluding data, states are allowed to pretend air quality is meeting the standard, when it is not,” said Leonard.
He said that according to EGLE’s own studies, even on days when wildfire smoke is present, the vast majority of ozone pollution in the Detroit area comes from other sources.
Leonard said that “85-90% is actually caused by our local industry. Only a small amount, 5-15%, is caused by wildfire smoke.”
Sandra Turner-Handy, the interim executive director of Detroiters Working for Environmental Justice, said she wants EGLE and the EPA to advocate for clean air in Detroit rather than seeking to exclude data.
According to the American Lung Association, Detroit was named the sixth-worst in the nation for year-round particle pollution in its 2025 report. In the 2024 report, the Detroit metro area was graded an F for ground-level ozone pollution.
“Our city has always been out of attainment – it’s a low-income community of color. Who cares but us that are living this lower quality of life?” said Turner-Handy.Turner-Handy said it is an environmental justice and racism issue and that the health of low-income communities of color needs more consideration.
Poor air quality in Detroit negatively impacts residents and stunts children’s growth and development, according to U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib, D-Detroit.
She said children can be more vulnerable to the negative effects of air pollution since their bodies are still developing.

“We already know that children cannot learn when they are being poisoned by our air and our water,” said Tlaib.
Children are at risk of getting hurt from natural causes that they cannot control, according to Mary-Jacqueline Muli, a climate justice nurse.
Speaking at the panel, she said she is doing a fellowship with the Alliance of Nurses for Healthy Environments to teach kids how to protect themselves and protect the air within their rooms.
However, Muli said that even when people make all the right choices, it still doesn’t fully protect them from complications from air pollution.

“It suggests that if a patient just makes the right choices that they will be safe. But how many people are making the right choices and are still not safe because of the environmental harms that we face?” said Muli.
According to EGLE, the department’s ultimate goal is to protect public health and improve air quality for Michigan communities.
An EGLE statement said the proposal would not hide air quality data and would not undermine negative health effects on the Detroit community.
“The use of exceptional events are in no way intended to minimize or discount the health of community members or the potential impacts of wildfire smoke. The data is a permanent part of the public record,” according to its statement.