Hundreds meet to discuss Toledo water quality, algae

Print More

ANCHOR INTRO: There was standing room only as more than 250 Toledo-area residents, farmers, and fishermen – along with scientists, environmental groups, and water, sewer officials from as far away as Cleveland — crowded into a conference room last Friday at Maumee Bay State Park. They were there to tell Ohio’s Lake Erie legislators what should be done to reduce the lake’s toxic algae — and protect drinking water for millions of residents. Producer Karen Schaefer reports:

Beaches outside rhe conference room in Maumee Bay were closed due to algae. Image: Karen Schaefer

Beaches outside the conference room in Maumee Bay were closed due to algae. Image: Karen Schaefer

AMBI: Gardner opening meeting, under:

SCHAEFER: As co-chairman state Senator Randy Gardner, a Republican from Bowling Green, opened the special Lake Erie legislative caucus, he warned attendees that testimony could take most of the day. And it did. For nearly six hours, people from across the state gave testimony and answered legislators’ questions. Adam Rissien of the Ohio Environmental Council led off by proposing that the Maumee River – whose farm run-off is the primary source of the algae – be declared a watershed in distress.

RISSIEN: So farmers and livestock producers will take swift action to implement a variety of best management practices in western Lake Erie basin’s largest watershed.

SCHAEFER: Representative Teresa Fedor, a Democrat from Toledo, was one of nearly half a million people affected by the recent shut down of her city’s water supply due to algae toxins. Fedor wanted to know why that designation hasn’t already been made.

RISSIEN: I would love to be able to tell you why that has not happened before now. Certainly the past history, especially in 2011 and again in 2013, when Carroll Township lost its water, you would think that would have been a step that was considered. I don’t have an answer for that.

SCHAEFER: The state’s Department of Natural Resources division of soil and water chief has the authority to declare a water body in distress when aquatic and human health are threatened by nutrients from agriculture. That’s already happened at Grand Lake St. Mary’s in western Ohio, where farmers are now required to restrict fertilizer and manure. Ohio Farm Bureau board president Bill Myers is a Lucas County farmer. He said the new state law that will start certifying fertilizer applicators in 2017 will achieve much the same goal, but will take too long. Myers offered a quicker solution.

MYERS: Instead of the three-year implementation, I think that in the Maumee watershed we ought to consider that, mandatory this winter, farmers have to get their certification. And that could happen.

SCHAEFER: Along with ideas about how to speed up the reduction of run-off, OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAwater treatment managers spoke about their need for better guidance from government officials. Ottawa County water chief Kelly Fry praised Governor Kasich’s pledge of a million dollars to help Lake Erie water districts pay for algae testing, still not required by the Ohio EPA. He’d like to take advantage of the state’s offer of 150-million dollars in no-interest loans to upgrade water and sewer plants. But Frey said he’s stymied, because there’s still no standard protocol for treating toxin-laden water.

FREY: My wish list is to know exactly what removes that microcystis from our plant. So that every day when I get up, I can be sure that it’s working properly, and I feel confident it’s going to be removed.

SCHAEFER: Caucus co-chair Representative Chris Redfern, a Democrat from Catawba is also the Ohio Democratic Party chairman, leading the charge for his Party’s nominees for statewide office. Redfern, whose district includes the Lake Erie Islands, blasted state environmental officials who blamed Toledo for failing to upgrade its aging water plant.

Ohio State Rep. Chris Redfern. Image: Karen Schaefer

Ohio State Rep. Chris Redfern. Image: Karen Schaefer

REDFERN: Attacking a water system for not coming up with a protocol? That responsibility rests squarely with two regulatory agencies in this country, the U.S. EPA and the Ohio EPA.

SCHAEFER: While the meeting didn’t produce a consensus on solutions, Redfern said it did give legislators some clear priorities for moving forward.

REDFERN: When you have fifteen legislators in a room full of people for the better part of six hours, that’s a very good step in the right direction. I’m heartened by this, I’m excited.

SCHAEFER: But Toledo Mayor Michael Collins was disheartened that fixing the problems is still going to take time.

COLLINS: My reaction to that is how much time do we

 Toledo Mayor Michael Collins is unhappy with delays in solving algae problems. Image: Karen Schaefer

Toledo Mayor Michael Collins is unhappy with delays in solving algae problems. Image: Karen Schaefer

have until we run out of time. The truth is the events that took place in Toledo, if that isn’t the alarm, I don’t know what it takes.

SCHAEFER: Collins is also concerned that most solutions will come with a big price tag. He and others at the meeting said they want to see US and Canadian federal governments get behind a single plan and create the funding to fix Lake Erie’s algae problems and keep drinking water safe.

For Great Lakes Echo, I’m Karen Schaefer.


Ohio Department of Natural Resources: Watershed in Distress

Related stories

Support for Karen Schaefer’s “Year of the Lake “ series is provided by the Ohio Sea Grant College Program at Ohio State University.

2 thoughts on “Hundreds meet to discuss Toledo water quality, algae

  1. If there are any reporters that’ve are Willing to cover a paradigm shift in science then email me at The ice boom is killing the entire lower great lakes ecosystem based on 50+ year old environmental impact studies.. we have to expose this now. JBB. ‘

  2. People listen to me. Your problem is caused at the other end of Lake Erie. The New York Power Authority has stopped the natural conveyor with their ice boom. It is like a plug in a drain. It keeps the lake from moving nutrients and sediments along. Yes there is phosphorus loading but it is compounded by the very un-natural stagnant ice sheet. Google “joe barrett/ice boom”. Thx JBB

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.