Great Lakes trumpeter swans are back

About 8,000 trumpeter swans are expected to be the results of a 2010 survey. Credit: Dr. Thomas G. Barnes/USFWS

It’s time to break out the brass band because trumpeter swans are back.

Standing up to 4-feet tall with up to an 8-foot wingspan, trumpeter swans are the largest waterfowl in North America. Their Great Lakes range includes: Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, New York and Ontario.

Early settlers hunted these birds nearly to extinction in the 1800s — using them to make powder puffs and feathered hats. But lack of exact records makes it impossible to guess the original population.

These settlers exported hundreds of thousands of carcasses, said Larry Gillette, wildlife manager of Minnesota’s Three Rivers Park District.

But trumpeter swans are back.

Preliminary results of a 2010 survey of Midwest states – from South Dakota to New York – are expected to yield 8,000 birds, said Joe Johnson, chief wildlife biologist emeritus of Michigan State University’s Kellogg Bird Sanctuary, who is compiling them.

But that’s just an estimate, he said.

The heart of the population is in the Great Lakes states, Ontario and Iowa, Johnson said.

States Vary

State/Province Trumpeter swan population
MN Nearly 6,000
WI 431 (in 2005) 183 nests counted in 2009
MI 400 (in 2005)
OH 150 – 200
ON 644 (in 2005)

And it varies dramatically from state to state.

A Minnesota aerial survey in early January tallied more than 5,000 birds in that state. By taking migrating birds into account, experts put the actual trumpeter number at nearly 6,000.

That’s a dramatic increase from the 2,000 trumpeters estimated in 2005 — and a huge jump from the 1970s.

“Basically, it was zero prior to 1979,” Gillette said.

In 1973, a swan restoration program started at Minnesota’s Three Rivers Park District with five swans. Later, eggs were taken from Alaska’s booming trumpeter swan population. These eggs hatched and the cygnets –young birds — were raised and released in Minnesota and other Great Lakes states.

At this point, we no longer bring eggs from Alaska or release birds, Gillette said.

They don’t do this in Ohio either, even though the bird has  been listed by the state as endangered since 1996.

There are about 150 to 200 trumpeters in Ohio, including – 30 nesting pairs, said Dave Sherman, a wildlife biologist with that state’s division of wildlife.

Ohio started swan restoration in the late 1990s long after other states like Minnesota. But there’s another reason their populations may be so different: the presence of wetlands —the habitat trumpeters prefer.

“Minnesota has far more wetland habitat than Ohio,” Sherman said.

Ohio has lost 90 percent of its wetlands, he said, which limits the swans that usually like large territories to themselves.

“We found that the birds are fairly adaptable and we’ve seen them in wetlands that are less than 20 acres, so they have adapted to the limited number of habitat that’s here in Ohio.”

Sherman is pleased with Ohio’s population, though he’d like to see 50 breeding pairs before it’s delisted.

But, Sherman doubts we’ll ever see numbers in the thousands.

 

Some consider the invasive mute swan a threat to trumpeters. Credit: Sean Varner/USFWS

Competitors

 

Lack of trumpeter habitat – mainly wetlands –  may not only be the threat to trumpeter swans.

 

Last week the Michigan Natural Resources Commission voted 3 to 2 to make it illegal to rehabilitate the invasive mute swan.

“Oh, we purposefully brought them here as an ornamental birds and they got away from us,” Johnson said.

The overpopulated invasive mutes compete with the trumpeter by taking up preferred nesting spots and bullying them.

“They’re a definitely a problem and we’re trying to minimized they’re impact on the trumpeter’s success,” Sherman said.

But Johnson has had other observations.

“My experience has been that the trumpeter swans dominate the mute swan,” Johnson said.In Michigan, Johnson said, trumpeters are purposefully released where no or few mute swans are present.

But Johnson admits that mute swans’ aggressive behavior can be a problem, especially for jet-skiers.

“When you get a 30-pound bird on you it’s a problem in the water,” he said.

An entire career

For those like Gillette, restoring the trumpeter swan back to the Great Lakes has been a life’s work.

He faced setbacks. Nine out of the 12 trumpeters first released were shot. In 1988, a drought lowered water levels and exposed lead bullets beneath the usual waterline. Many trumpeters died of lead poisoning.

He says the setbacks are worth it.

“Yeah it’s very gratifying,” he said. “It’s a heck of a commitment and basically a whole career.”

  • bbezr

    Good job guyes

  • Bonnie

    We have been really blessed with trumpeter swans for at least five years.
    But, sad to say we have 2-3 die each spring-summer season. One just got killed
    by a car last week. We have yet seen young produced because of one of the
    mates will be killed before the seasons ends. Very sad. We live on a busy county
    road that runs through two parcels of old muckland turned into wetlands. This past
    2012 January, five swans flew in to check it out. Left then came again in Febuary.
    Two pairs stayed to make this their nesting ground. Now one swims alone. I
    e-mailed the DEC to tell them about the swans being killed. They wrote back to
    Inform me to get intouch with our county highway department for signs. I will be doing
    that this week. It has been really hard on us seeing these birds slaughtered
    In this way. Not only swans but geese , ducks, turtles. The lists goes on and on.
    Let you know how it turns out. Sorry, just had to vent to someone. Sincerely , a Bird Lover from NY. :)

  • Anonymous

    mute swans aren t bulliers they can just be aggressive sometimes

  • marianne

    I sure hope nature will survive all the missers people have made during the centuries. There are so many beautifull animals disapeaered already, shame on us humans.

  • Bob

    Disappearing wetlands is a problem all over the country but it is good to hear that these birds are making a comeback with limited habitat. Unless we get our population under control there is little chance that we will rehabilitate many wetland areas.

    As for the lead, my guess is that lead shot is common in all wetlands that ever supported birds. Thanks for the update.

  • Mark

    Love your writing, Keep up the good work.

    Sincerely,
    Mark

  • Wayne

    I live at Cooke Dam on Michigans AuSable river. We have over 100 overwintering Trumpeters in the open water here. Also there are several nesting pairs here. What a wonderful sight to see these birds year around. Thanks to all that made this great effort a reality.

  • Chris

    Nice story. Well done.

  • http://CoverThePlanet.org David Poulson

    Alan – Thanks. Fixed.

  • Alan

    Typo in the second picture — should be “invasive mute swan” — yes?

  • Harold

    “In 1988, a drought lowered water levels and exposed lead bullets beneath the usual waterline.”

    The problem wasn’t a “drought”–it was that lead shot was purposefully scattered throughout most of our wetlands by hunters. It’s time for all lead shot and lead fishing weights to be banned. Period.